Our Night at Don Angie in New York: No Reservation, Five People
People talk about getting a Don Angie reservation like it’s a lottery. Blink and it’s gone. Refresh, pray, move on. We had never been and we didn’t get a reservation, which is no surprise based on my feelings towards reservations. So we figured we’d be doomed to a plan B of grabbing pizza at Joe’s and head into The The Four-Faced Liar that offers BYOF (a pretty great plan B).
Well, we gave it a try.
I showed up early. Or at least I thought I did. Two hours early (more on that to come). Third in line. Not bad. I figured we had a shot. When I asked, they said I should be okay. Calm. Friendly. No attitude. Actually, extremely nice. What was happening? This isn’t the New York dining scene people talk about from 2,000 miles away who have never been…Hmmm…
Then I realized they opened at 3:30. Not 4:30, like I thought. My group wasn’t there yet. Five people. Now I know we were doomed. The kind of situation that usually gets you a polite “no chance.” A busy restaurant like this isn’t going to hold a specific reservation for a table of five at a specific time an hour after opening. Right? They can’t hold the table because the 50-person line behind me would want to sit as soon as possible. An hour after opening would also mean every newly seated table would still be in the middle of their meals and drinks.
My heart dropped. And then I got to the front of the line, laughed at myself, and asked, like a fool.
“4:30 works.”
Just like that. Easy. Smiling. No stress. Need a high chair? They didn’t care. A stroller? They made it sound easy. It set the tone right away. We were in and only because the staff were so great to us. We went on April 17th, by the way…if anyone reading this works at Don Angie and wants to check who was running the door…and couldn’t have had a better experience.
The room isn’t huge, but it feels alive. Open, but still shaped with purpose. Tables tucked in tight. A beautiful bar running along the side like the spine of the place. Marble, soft light, bottles lined up like they know they’re being watched. And everyone is watching. Servers are weaving through tight gaps between conversations. Dates looked intimate, groups were having fun, and families were enjoying it all, which only a great room and curated ambience and earned anticipation can create.
Menus in hand, we slowed down a bit. You don’t rush this part. It’s built for sharing. Built for talking it out. What are we getting? What are we not missing? Who’s committing to what? The usual group dynamic. Huddling up to do the verbal dance around fighting for the dishes you really believe in, and being as polite as possible for the ones you do not care about. Luckily, at a spot like Don Angie, they’re all bangers.
You start spotting the hits right away. The stuff you’ve seen online. The dishes you came for, whether you admit it or not. The appetizers, the mains, the pastas with names you pretend you know how to say, the ones you Googled before coming so you could pretend like you knew it all along. Like, yes, you fool, of course I know what “da Pepi” means, it’s a historic, famous eatery in Trieste, Italy, founded in 1897. The name translates to "Pepi's Buffet" or "At Pepi's Buffet," referring to a place specializing in traditional Austro-Hungarian-style boiled pork meats, sauerkraut, and horseradish.
At some point, you look around again for inspiration. Every table is locked in. Dates leaning in. Groups passing plates. The bar is full. People standing, waiting, hoping for a seat. You see the dish you hoped to order. “hey everyone!” you yell, “Look at all the flatbreads! Pretttttty popular!” you also yell, not so subtly.
“Snapping back to reality now.” The food started coming in.
The stuffed garlic flatbread. Big. Golden. Cheese tucked inside. Crispy outside. Sooo garlicky. You pull it apart and it stretches in that perfect, dramatic way. It’s rich. It goes perfectly with the chrysanthemum salad. Maybe it all goes good together, or maybe we were perfect orderers. The salad seems like it was the responsible choice. And it is. Kind of. It’s light, but still made with parmesan everywhere, garlic, sesame, crunch. I took the salad and topped the flatbread with it. You can do that too if you go!
We leaned into cocktails first (they don’t call me hoagie-negroni for nothing). Clean. Cold. Gone (too) quickly. Then wine. Italian. One bottle of Tuscan red turns into two. Then we went truly wild with a third bottle, this time Lambrusco. You can do that too if you go!
Our favourite single bite of the night was probably the alberjack crudo made with coconut brodo, pine nut, and spring pesto. Like any crudo, it’s in the details, the chance to turn a blank canvas of fresh salt with the perfect texture and play around with it. Too little and it’s overpriced and boring. Too much, and it’s drowned out, might as well have been chicken. I understand this dish is seasonal, and we are so happy we tried it, even if not choosing the spicy veal tartare and tuna carpaccio was a very difficult one.
And then it arrived…the infamous Lasagna for Two.
You see a dish this hyped, you brace yourself. It’s either life-changing or a letdown. Usually somewhere in the middle.
This one… totally worked. Not the heavy, stacked square you expect, even though I still love those. This one is rolled. Tight. Portion-ready. Edges crisped up. Designed to be shared without the awkward scooping and collapsing. You cut into it, and it holds. Layers still there. Just rethought. Pasta, sauce, cheese.
It’s familiar. Comforting. Not a pretentious change just to be clever. It’s still what you know and love. Each piece feels finished. Not messy. Not falling apart. Just… right. Like any great art or story told, it has a simple “why didn’t I think of that?” quality.
Also, it’s big. Actually big. Not “fine dining big.” Real portion. You pass it around, and everyone gets a proper piece. No fighting for scraps. Apparently, even in the small room, they will sell over a hundred on a busy night and even have a dedicated walk-in cooler for just lasagnas. I’m actually thinking of getting a walk-in lasagna cooler for my place.
We added more pastas. Had to. We were here.
The buffalo milk caramelle was like twisted carb candy. Striped. Filled with that rich buffalo milk ricotta, sitting in brown butter with a hit of black sesame and citrus from the kumquat. Sweet, salty, a little nutty.
Garganelli giganti made with big tubes covered in a broken meatball ragù with guanciale and pecorino. Again, it’s elevated, but comforting. Deep, meaty, heavy in the best way. Perfect date dish.
We kept going.
The stracchino gnocchi comes coated in a creamy sauce with truffle and mushrooms. Pillowy. Again, comfort food turned all the way up. We ate it with a main dish, a shell steak al limone that was charred outside, but bright from the lemon, sliced and ready to share. It cut through everything we had just eaten.
New York has no shortage of places to eat. Pizza spots you wait in line for (L’Industrie) even though there’s world-class slices around the corner (Lucali). Bagel counters (Tompkins) you defend like family. Bars you go back to without thinking (McSorleys). And Italian restaurants… endless.
But this felt like one of the modern greats.
The kind where you sit a little longer. Order another drink. You feel taken care of in every way, from the first moment you line up way too early because you hate reservations, to the final moment when you leave so full you can barely walk down Greenwich Ave and grab a brown butter cookie dough froyo from Birdies (but you still do).
When you’re spending this kind of money, in this kind of city, spending your evening moments somewhere, that matters.
Come with a group. Or a date. Show up early. Try your luck. Because now you know you might even get in, and that it’s going to be worth it if you do.
AUTHOR: Hogan short
Follow me on Beli and see my ranked lists in every city I’ve been to!
Follow me on Instagram and see other stuff I get up to!
For more food stories like this, check out our weekly newsletter.
